The price to look at is last month's
Black Friday falls on Friday 27 November, but many deals have already started. Before buying, it helps to know what the authorities found the last time they checked.
During Black Friday and Cyber Monday 2025, consumer authorities in 23 EU countries, plus Iceland and Norway, examined 314 online shops selling cosmetics, fashion, furniture and electrical goods, all at the same time. The results, published by the European Commission on 26 March, show that 30% displayed discounts incorrectly.1 Another 34% compared their own price with a reference price, and six times out of ten did not explain where that price came from.2 Then there are the tricks that have nothing to do with the price tag: items slipped into the basket, countdown timers, charges that only appear at the end.
The rule those discounts broke is simple, and it has been in force in Italy for more than three years. A discount is not calculated on the crossed-out price but on the lowest price the shop charged in the previous 30 days.
What the 30-day rule says
It comes from EU Directive 2019/2161, known as the Omnibus Directive, which added an article to the old directive on price indication. It has applied across the EU since 28 May 2022.3 Italy transposed it with Legislative Decree 26 of 2023, which added article 17-bis to the Consumer Code, covering promotional campaigns from 1 July 2023.4
The text is short. Every announcement of a price reduction must state the prior price, meaning the lowest price the trader applied to consumers in general during the previous thirty days. The exceptions are few, and they explain some price tags that look odd. Perishable food is excluded. For a product on sale for less than 30 days, the shop must say which period the prior price refers to, and "launch prices" followed by an announced increase fall outside the rule. If the discount grows during the same campaign without a break, from 20 to 30 to 40%, the reference stays the price before the first reduction. Offers reserved for individual customers or groups, such as loyalty card holders, do not count in the calculation, because the law refers to consumers in general. The same goes for sales below cost.
For a while one question remained open: is it enough to state the lowest price of the month somewhere, or must the percentage actually be calculated on it? The Court of Justice of the EU answered on 26 September 2024, in the Aldi Süd case. In the German chain's weekly leaflets, among bananas and pineapples, one product was advertised on offer at 1.29 euros, next to the price charged just before, 1.69. But the lowest price of the past 30 days was exactly 1.29, so there was no discount. According to the Court, both the percentage and claims such as "price highlight" must be calculated on the 30-day minimum, precisely to stop shops raising the price just before announcing a reduction.5
For this year's Black Friday the sum is easy. For a discount that starts on 27 November, the reference is the lowest price between 28 October and 26 November. If the offer began on 20 November, the window moves back a week and starts on 21 October.
What the checks find in Italy
QBerg, an Italian company that tracks online prices, compares Black Friday promotions every year with the lowest price of the same model, on the same site, in the previous 30 days. On 28 November 2025 it checked 65 electronics and appliance sites, including general retailers, specialists and manufacturers' own shops, covering 116,104 models. Of the 31,245 offers presented as promotions, 39.5% broke the rule.6 A year earlier the figure was 25.5%, in 2023 it was 16%.7
Black Friday promotions breaking the rule in Italy
On the same day 12.8% of prices were higher than on the Friday before, with an average rise of 11.7% on the products that went up. For built-in appliances, non-compliant promotions reached 47.1%.6
In January 2026, well away from Black Friday, the consumer association Altroconsumo looked at the 208 most used online shops in Italy. Only 24% used the lowest price of the previous month as the reference. A further 41% showed only a crossed-out full price next to the discounted one, without saying where the first came from, and 21% calculated the discount on an average price, the manufacturer's recommended price or other references. The association sent its results to the competition authority and asked for guidelines.8 Shoppers already suspect as much: in an Altroconsumo survey of more than 2,000 people in November 2025, more than half thought some shops raise prices before Black Friday.9
In France the best-known case concerns Shein. In July 2025 the French consumer authority fined the company 40 million euros after tracking prices on its French site from October 2022 to August 2023. In 57% of the listings checked there was no reduction at all, in 19% the reduction was smaller than claimed, and in 11% the "promotion" was in fact a price increase.10
Who checks, and what getting it wrong costs
In Italy there are two routes, and they carry very different weight. A breach of article 17-bis is punished with the penalty that the 1998 retail law sets for special sales: one to six million lire, or roughly 516 to 3,098 euros, imposed by the mayor of the town where it happened.11 For a large online shop that is not a frightening sum.
When a fake discount misleads buyers, though, it becomes an unfair commercial practice, and the competition authority (AGCM) steps in, with fines from 5,000 euros to 10 million.12 Between November 2025 and June 2026 it closed at least three cases on online retail.
The first, which started from a request by the Belgian authority, concerned Boggi, which calculated discounts on the list price instead of the 30-day minimum. The AGCM accepted the company's commitments, under which it must send anyone who bought on promotion between 1 April 2024 and 31 May 2025 a voucher worth the difference plus 10%, valid for twelve months.13 In February it was the turn of Bernabei, which sells drinks and spirits online, fined 400,000 euros: many products "on offer" cost as much as or more than the 30-day minimum, and the crossed-out prices had never been charged, or only rarely.14
The third case, in June, is the most telling. Deghi, which sells furniture and homeware, used countdown timers from January 2024 to the end of 2025 that restarted identically when they ran out. During an inspection the chairman of the board acknowledged that discounts were calculated on the full price, not on the 30-day minimum. In a file dated 31 October 2025, between 20,000 and 30,000 items kept the same price and the same discount percentage from one month to the next. The fine was 2 million euros.1215
What I think
The 30-day rule is a good rule, and the Italian cases show the AGCM enforces it. But it has a limit buyers should know about, because it only looks at the previous month. A price raised well in advance, 31 days before the discount, becomes the new legal reference.
A British study illustrates it, even though the UK no longer applies EU directives. The consumer group Which? tracked the prices of 175 products at eight large retailers for a year, from May 2024 to May 2025. Of these, 83% were the same price or cheaper at least once outside the sales period, and none was at its lowest price of the year on Black Friday itself. A Samsung robot vacuum cost 299 pounds in May and June, 399 in August and September, 500 in the first week of October, then 350 "on offer".16 Even under the EU rule, anyone who remembered the spring price would have paid more.
That is why I would not put much weight on the percentage printed in red. The number that matters is the price history over three or six months. And I think the rules should go a step further. Shops already have the data, because to calculate the 30-day minimum they must keep prices day by day: showing a small chart next to the offer would cost little. I would also raise the article 17-bis penalty, which at a maximum of about 3,098 euros weighs less than what an inflated discount brings a large shop.
This year there is one more reason to look further back. Many electronic products cost more than a year ago, because memory chips are going to AI data centres.17 A genuine discount on last month can still be a higher price than last Christmas.
How to check a discount before paying
- On the pageFind the 30-day priceThe lowest price of the previous month must be shown, and the percentage must be calculated from it. If it is missing, or matches the offer price, there is no discount.
- Before buyingLook at the historyPrice comparison sites and some browser extensions show how the price has moved over recent months. A real discount takes the price below the lows of the previous months.
- Facing a timerCome back the next dayA countdown that restarts identically when it runs out is a banned practice. Reopening the page after the deadline is enough to spot it.
- At checkoutReread the basketRemove warranties and accessories you did not choose, and compare the total, shipping included, with the price you first saw.
Here is an example built on the rule, with a product that almost always costs 129 euros and was on a four-day flash sale in early November.
The same discount, counted two ways
| Item | Price | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Crossed-out price | 129 euros | The full price, charged most of the year |
| Lowest price from 28 October to 26 November | 99 euros | The flash sale in early November |
| Black Friday price | 90.30 euros | 30% off the crossed-out price |
| Discount to announce | 9% | Calculated on the 99 euros, as the law requires |
If a discount looks wrong, the best evidence is a screenshot of the page with the date and time, together with one of the price history. In Italy you can report it to the AGCM through the online form on its site, by certified email or by post, without a lawyer. The authority does not refund individual customers: to get the difference back you have to ask the shop or go to court.18 For a shop based in another EU country there is the network of European Consumer Centres.1
For an offer that starts on 27 November, the price to look for is the lowest seen since 28 October. Anyone who added a product to their wish list a month ago and set a price alert already has the figure they need.