“Sooner than expected” · Privacy

Meta fined €805 million: Facebook was reading the phone's camera roll

Italy's data protection authority has fined Meta over Facebook's access to the photos and videos of about 20 million Android users. What it decided, what it left out and how to switch the feature off.

Line drawing: a smartphone seen from the front with its screen split into a grid of nine photos; a large black magnifying glass comes in from the right over two of them, while a switch at the bottom is still on.
The permission given to post one photo covered the whole camera roll, and the suggestions switch was already on.

Listen to the episode

Podcast episode in Italian · 10 min. The voice is mine, recreated with artificial intelligence.

In short

  • On 14 November 2026 Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, fined Meta Platforms Ireland €805 million: the Facebook app for Android accessed camera roll photos, videos and metadata without specific consent. About 20 million users in Italy are affected.
  • The feature “Get camera roll suggestions when you're browsing Facebook” has existed since 2023 and was switched on by default. Within 60 days Meta must turn it off by default for everyone and ask for separate consent. The fine is about 0.47% of the group's worldwide turnover, and the law goes up to 4%.
  • The case does not cover AI training or the newer feature that processes photos in the cloud. Facebook users can switch off the suggestions and remove the app's permission for photos and videos in a few minutes.

What the Garante decided on 14 November

On 14 November Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, announced a fine of €805 million against Meta Platforms Ireland, the company that runs Facebook in Europe. According to the authority, the Facebook app for Android accessed photographs, videos and their metadata stored on Italian users' phones without specific consent and without telling them properly.1

The feature is called “Get camera roll suggestions when you're browsing Facebook” and has existed since 2023. As you scroll, it shows photos and videos taken from the phone's camera roll as ideas for a post. These are pictures nobody ever uploaded to Facebook, and a camera roll holds all sorts, from photos of your children to a snapshot of an ID card.

The inquiry began in July 2025 with a report from the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, a consumer association in Bolzano, which on 11 July had published the two settings it found in the app and advised people to switch them off. One of them said that while browsing Facebook you would occasionally see photos and videos from your camera roll, as a reminder that new sharing suggestions were available.2

The Garante then ran its own technical analysis, which produced three findings. Access to the camera roll was requested through a single authorisation, valid for the whole app and for quite different features. The notice shown before it spoke vaguely of “enabling other features” and never mentioned camera roll suggestions. Finally, the feature was already switched on.

Within 60 days Meta must ask for consent through a separate request, explain what the feature is for and how to turn it off, and keep it off by default even for people who have already given the authorisation. It must tell the Garante within 30 days what it has started and within 90 what it has done.1

€805 millionthe fine against Meta Platforms IrelandGarante, 14 November 2026
20 millionAndroid users affected in Italy, roughlyGarante, 14 November 2026
0.47%of the group's worldwide turnover, roughlyGarante, 14 November 2026
60 daysto switch the feature off and ask for separate consentGarante, 14 November 2026

One permission for the whole camera roll

The technical heart of the case is the Android permission. When an app asks to see photos and videos the system shows a dialogue, and since Android 14 the user can also grant access to selected pictures only.3 If they grant everything, the app can read the entire photo archive, as a rule permanently. The Garante notes that at that point neither the user nor the authority can check which information is actually used.1

People who grant that permission usually have one thing in mind, which is posting a photo. According to the Garante the same permission also served a different feature, one the user had not asked for and found already on.

The rule that was broken is Article 122 of Italy's Privacy Code, which implements the EU ePrivacy Directive. It says that accessing information already stored on a user's device is allowed only if the user has consented after being informed, unless the access is strictly necessary to provide a service the user has explicitly requested.4 It is the same rule that governs cookies. The Garante reads it this way: the phone is part of a person's private sphere, and consent is needed for the mere fact of going in, even if no data is transmitted and even if no harm is done.1

Meta describes the feature in more modest terms. In the app screen reproduced by the British consumer group Which?, it says it uses basic metadata, such as when photos were taken or which are marked as favourites, and that the suggestions can be turned off at any time.5 For Article 122 the difference matters little, because the rule is triggered by the access itself, whatever is done with it afterwards.

Why Rome decided, and what the figure is worth

Meta argued that the case belonged to the Irish authority, since the group has its European headquarters in Ireland. That is how it works under the GDPR: the “one-stop shop” hands the investigation to the country where the company is based. The ePrivacy rules have no such mechanism, and the Garante rejected the objection.1 That is why Rome could decide.

For the Garante this is a change of scale. In February 2024 the Garante fined Enel Energia €79,107,101 and called it the highest penalty the authority had ever imposed.6 The one against Meta is ten times that. In 2019 the fine on Facebook over Cambridge Analytica was €1 million.7 Among the factors that pushed the amount up, the Garante cites a previous decision against the company from 2019, without saying which in the press release, and poor cooperation during the inquiry.1

The Garante's fines, in millions of euros

Meta, November 2026805
Enel Energia, February 202479.1
Facebook, June 20191
Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, press releases of 14 November 2026, 29 February 2024 and 28 June 2019. In February 2024 the Garante called the Enel Energia fine the highest it had ever imposed.

Yet the law would have allowed far more. For breaches of Article 122 the Code refers to the GDPR's heaviest penalties, which go up to 4% of worldwide annual turnover.89 The Garante says €805 million is about 0.47% of the group's turnover. The rest of the arithmetic is mine: on that proportion the ceiling would be just under €7 billion, and the fine, divided by the 20 million users affected, comes to about €40 each.

Nor is any of this quick. The Enel Energia fine was upheld by the Court of Rome in a judgment published on 18 September 2025, more than a year and a half later, and according to the note the Garante added to its press release the appeal is still pending.6 Meta replied the same day. A spokesperson said the company is “in strong disagreement with the assessment of the facts and with the Garante's application of the law” and considers the amount disproportionate. The spokesperson added that the feature works only after a permission granted on the phone, which can be changed in the settings, and closed with four words: “We intend to appeal”.10 The statement does not say before which court, or when.

What is left out

The case does not concern the training of artificial intelligence. The Garante says so explicitly and adds that Meta denies using camera roll content for that purpose.1

The newer feature is left out as well. On 16 April 2026 Meta brought to the European Union and the United Kingdom the suggestions that analyse camera roll photos to propose edits, collages and videos. In its announcement the company says the feature is opt-in, that only the user sees the suggestions and that camera roll photos and videos are not used to improve its AI unless the user publishes them or shares them with an AI feature.11 In June 2025, when a version was being tested in the United States, TechCrunch reported the wording of the prompt: media from the camera roll would be uploaded to Meta's servers on an “ongoing basis”.12 That test is not the feature that was fined, and it may not match the version that reached Europe either. On cloud processing the Garante reserves the right to carry out separate checks.1

The press release speaks only of the Android app and says nothing about the iPhone one. Nor does it link to the full text of the decision, so what I write here comes from the press release.

From the report to the fine

  1. Feb 2024A €79.1 million fine for Enel Energia, then the Garante's highest
  2. Jul 2025The Bolzano consumer association reports the feature and the inquiry begins
  3. Apr 2026Meta brings opt-in suggestions that analyse photos to Europe
  4. Nov 2026An €805 million fine for Meta and 60 days to change the feature

What I think

I think the Garante is right, and not only about Facebook. Consent given once to post a photo became a pass for a feature nobody had asked for and which started switched on. Hardly anyone opens an app's settings, and those who do need to know what they are looking for. Requiring one clear question per feature, with no as the starting point, seems to me the least we should expect. The same goes for the products I wrote about in the piece on glasses with a camera.

It also matters where all this started. A consumer association in Bolzano published a settings screen and wrote to the Garante.2 Sixteen months later came a fine ten times what had been the record in 2024. This is what associations and public authorities are for, and they manage it when they have the people and the means to run a technical analysis of their own, without having to rely on what the company declares.

I am less impressed by the amount. A sum worth 0.47% of turnover is one a group of that size can budget for, and Meta has already said it will challenge it, as Enel Energia did. For people who use Facebook the other half of the decision matters more: the feature off by default for everyone, including those who had already said yes. If that is how phones look when the 60 days are up, the decision will have worked. If the consent request arrives with “yes” in plain view and the refusal two screens further on, we will be back where we started.

What to do on your phone, without waiting

The Garante warns that the breach is ongoing for anyone who has not updated the app and for anyone who has already granted the system authorisation.1 Checking takes a few minutes. The names of the settings may vary slightly between versions of the app and between phone brands.513

  1. Update FacebookThe changes Meta made after the report apply only to people who have updated the app, according to the Garante.
  2. Switch off the suggestionsIn the app open the menu, then Settings & privacy, Settings, and look for “Camera roll sharing suggestions”. Turn off the options you find.
  3. Remove or limit the permissionOn Android: Settings, Apps, Facebook, Permissions, Photos and videos. Choose “Don't allow”, or grant selected photos only if your phone offers it.
  4. Look at the other appsIn Android's settings permissions can also be viewed by type: the list shows every app that can read photos and videos.

On an iPhone the path is Settings, Privacy & Security, Photos, Facebook.5 With access limited to selected photos you can still post, choosing each time what to show the app.

Counting from 14 November, the 30 days run out in mid-December and the 60 in mid-January 2027.

Notes and sources

  1. Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, Facebook: the Garante fines Meta €805 million ↗ (in Italian), press release of 14 November 2026. ↩
  2. Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, Facebook accesses unpublished photos ↗ (in Italian), 11 July 2025. ↩
  3. Android Developers, Grant partial access to photos and videos ↗, Android 14 documentation. ↩
  4. Legislative Decree no. 196 of 30 June 2003 (Italian Privacy Code), Article 122 ↗ (in Italian), text in force on Normattiva. ↩
  5. Which?, Facebook could be accessing your photos: here's how to stop it ↗, 21 October 2025. ↩
  6. Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, Telemarketing: Italian Data Protection Authority sanctions Enel Energia ↗, press release of 29 February 2024, with the note on Court of Rome judgment no. 12783/2025. ↩
  7. Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, Cambridge Analytica: the Garante fines Facebook €1 million ↗ (in Italian), press release of 28 June 2019. ↩
  8. Legislative Decree no. 196 of 30 June 2003, Article 166(2) ↗ (in Italian), text in force on Normattiva. ↩
  9. Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR), Article 83(5) ↗. ↩
  10. Adnkronos, Garante Privacy fines Meta €805 million. The company replies: “We will appeal” ↗ (in Italian), 14 November 2026. ↩
  11. Meta, Now Rolling Out: Facebook's Opt-In Camera Roll Suggestions ↗, 16 April 2026. ↩
  12. S. Perez, TechCrunch, Facebook is asking to use Meta AI on photos in your camera roll you haven't yet shared ↗, 27 June 2025. ↩
  13. Google, Android Help, Change app permissions on your Android phone ↗. ↩